Australian PrehistoryAustralian HistoryAustralian CultureAustralian Sport Australian Native animals

Homepage

Creativity

Architects
Understatement vs overstatement

Craft
Emotion through the hands
Cuisine
Breaking the rules of fine dining
Fashion
Ugg boots on the catwalk
Humour
Mogrels, wogs, and larrikins
Inventions
Thinking different
Movies
Once were blockbusters...
Music
Pushing the boundaries
Painting
The value of tradition
Poetry
Defying stoicism
Wine
Discovering culture
Wisdom
Australian quotes

 

E-mail

 

 

Australian architecture
Australian architecture
Understatement vs overstatement

Australia has had a little over two centuries of urban civilisation. In those two centuries, various immigrants have tried to adapt the architectural concepts of their homeland to the unique challenges of Australia. Due to cultural or environmental influences, many of these adaptations have not always been successful.  

Although the adaptations have not always been successful, they have brought new ideas, and out of the mixing pots of ideas a new architectural style is emerging. It is a style fluctuating between over-statement and understatement as architects seek to either gain a symbolic dominance over the land and the culture, or find a harmony with it.

The harmonious ideas can be seen in the bush architects of Glen Murcutt and Greg Burgess. The domineering ideas can be seen in the magnificent bluestone buildings of Melbourne that show greed is good, and wealth should be flaunted.

Bush architecture

The Bush

Early bush architecture was always understated. This was largely because the harsh Australian environment made it difficult to construct buildings of grandeur. Unlike the straight-grained trees of the northern hemisphere, Australian eucalypts are wonky. Any builder using them just had to accept that there would be gaps in their walls, their roof would not be straight, and prestige would not be a feature of their house.

To cope with poor building materials, early pioneers imported corrugated iron sheeting. Light but strong, the sheeting was the perfect roof that could be transported from steel factories on the coast to the isolated interior. Although corrugated sheeting was generally associated with low status constructions, because Australia's pioneers had become accustomed to understatement they just didn't care.

Kempsey shorthouse
Glen Murcutt - Kempsey shorthouse

The sentiments expressed in these early buildings have inspired a new generation of architects seeking an Australian style. The leading architect of the genre is Glen Murcutt, winner of the Pritzker ( the noble prize of the profession.) Murcutt takes the understatement of the bush shacks and infuses into them the refined concepts of modern architecture. Murcutt pays close attention to the movement of the sun, moon, and seasons in order to harmonise his buildings with the movement of light and wind. This interior of modernity and refinement makes a strange juxtaposition with the exterior of heritage and toughness.

Greg Burgess - Uluru Cultural Centre

Another bush architect is Greg Burgess. Whereas Murcutt's designs are understated rectangular forms, Burgess' designs seem to remould the earth in flowing curves. Perhaps his most notable work is the Uluru Cultural Centre. The building seems to have been carved from the red earth by some great dreamtime flood.

Wasted Space


Canberra

"I have planned a city not like any other in the world . . . . I have planned an ideal city" Walter Burley Griffin

From a perspective of urban design and architecture, Canberra is one of the world's most fascinating cities. Built with the generous funds of the federal government with the aim of creating a rival to Paris and New York, urban planners and architects had the money to create a utopia. Furthermore, they had a clean slate to work with. Without traditional styles or entrenched landholding interests to constrain them, planners had complete freedom to implement all their own ideas. On the whole, their ideas failed and in many cases, the outcome was at the polar opposite to the intended outcome. Needless to say, Canberra is not spoken in the same breath as New York or Paris.

While success may be inspiring, failure is very interesting. In the case of Canberra, its failure reveals a great deal about the limits of feel-good ideology and transient theory to successfully integrate principles of economics, aesthetics, useability, sociology, psychology and environment in a way that that appeals to a community, and gives that community the ability to adapt across time.

In 1910 American architect Walter Burley Griffin won a world-wide competition to design Australia's capital. Griffin was heavily influenced by the concept of a "garden city" outlined in Ebenezer Howard's book "Tomorrow: A Peaceful Path to Real Reform", published in 1898. Howard believed in environmental determinism, and blamed poor surroundings for the moral and social failings of urban life. As a solution to moral decline, Howard proposed self-contained cities of about 30,000 people surrounded by parks and ‘home farms’ in which every house would have its own garden. Ironically, rather than be a beacon of moral virtue, Canberra became known for four 'P's' that represented four different vices of humanity - pyrotechnics, pornography, pot and politicians. The home gardens were great for growing marijuana and the privacy that low density living allows seemed conducive to the take up of porn.

In 1967, the National Capital Development Commission was established to fulfil the spirit of the garden city. It decided this could be achieved with the "Y-Plan." The plan aimed to decentralise Canberra into seven different districts roughly in the shape of a Y. Each district would have a town centre, which would be the focus of commercial and social activities. The districts would also be divided into smaller suburbs each with their own shops and schools.

In theory, having self-contained districts would reduce the need for the car, and realise the moral virtue of Howard's garden city concept. In practice, a city designed to reduce the need for the car became dependent on it. While it all sounded nice to have self-contained districts, in practice few people had the employment and residential mobility that allowed them to live and work in the same district. As residents found themselves living and working in different districts, Canberra planners had to build a Las Angeles style freeway network to serve a population of less than 300,000 people. Some of the area between the districts became parks that no one used. Some became cork farms, sheep farms, or just sun-burnt grass that was too expensive to maintain.

Just as citizens didn't behave as expected, neither did private enterprise. Business located themselves in the central district instead of its outer districts. It was in the central district where businesses could maximise their accessibility to the maximum number of potential customers, locate themselves close to interdependent industries, and gain awareness in people's minds. As specialisation is limited to market size, the central district could in turn offer a greater variety of refined and niche choices, which in turn reinforced its status in the minds of consumer. As for the outer districts, they ended up being used as shopping malls and public service outposts.

In addition to decentralisation, planners also wanted to create an egalitarian city. They didn't want the prestige real-estate on the waterfront or hill tops locked up in private hands. Consequently, planning laws reserved prime real-estate for public use. While it was a nice gesture to save land for the public, the public rarely used the land. On the waterfront and hill tops there just wasn't anything to attract people. No restaurants, no houses, and no sense of activity. Consequently, the prime real-estate ended up being ignored or used for car parks.

 

Cameron Offices - Crushed Car

Cameron Offices - Brutalist

As well egalitarian sentiments being expressed in Canberra's urban design, they are also expressed in its architecture. Brutalism is the most notable of the egalitarian style. Brutalism originated in Britain in the 1950s. It had an ethical concern for an honesty in the materials used and the centrality of the user in the design of the building. Somewhat consistent with the spirit of soviet style socialism, brutal architecture makes heavy use of off-form concrete, unpretentious slabs of blank grey wall and sharp angles.

The Cameron Offices were very interesting works of brutalist architecture that ultimately failed as a consequence of whimsical views of urban planners. The concrete buildings consisted of a series of pavilions linked by walkways. Gardens filled the void between each pavilion. The design planned to link the offices with a pedestrian shopping centre. Shops would be located beneath the offices, and around them and pedestrians would meander their way through.

The plan failed to be realised when, at the 11th hour, a shopping mall was built on the opposite side of the main street. Public servants in the offices then started complaining about their isolation from the mall. In addition to their feelings of isolation, the public servants complained that the offices vibrated, and felt cold.  

The government eventually sold the offices on condition they be demolished and replaced with car parks. Recognising their historical and architectural value, in 2005, the Royal Australian Institute of Architects added the offices to their register of buildings of national significance. The move was of little use, and in 2008 most of the offices were demolished to make way for the car park. Poetically, in the demolition process, a concrete slab fell down and crushed a car.

 

High Court of Australia - Brutalist

In 1981, Canberra gained its first example of brutalist architecture with the unveiling of the High Court of Australia. As a concrete monstrosity, the High Court effectively conveys a feeling of strength in the law as it dominates the Canberra foreshore.

Australian Parliament House - In Harmony with Australian values and the ladnscape

While the brutalist architecture may have been designed with the people in mind, the general populice was not particularly fond of it. In 1988, the unveiling of Parliament House showed that egalitarian sentiments can be expressed in way that is a little more easy on the eyes. Unlike the National Gallery and the High Court, the work is of a similar style to that of Greg Burgess in that it blends into the landscape. In fact, the majority of the building is buried underground. Symbolically, Parliament House also reflects the Australian national spirit by expressing that the individual is more powerful than the government. Wide lawn arches rise over the building to allow the people to climb on top of their government, thus symbolising their power over it. In this way, Parliament House seems to marry Australia's egalitarian ideals, with the understatement of the bush.

Sydney

Sydney

'there can be few things more pleasing than the contemplation of order and useful management arising gradually out of tumult and confusion ' Arthur Phillip - first governor of Australia

Francis Greenway - Hyde Park Barracks

In terms of building materials, Sydney gains its uniqueness from the sandstone upon which it is built. The first architect to use the sandstone was the convict Francis Greenway. Greenway was enlisted by Governor Macquarie to design buildings that would encourage emancipists to see the colony as a home rather than a campsite for prisoners. Greenway achieved his aim with solid brick constructions that conveyed an underlying theme of strength and permanency. Notable works include: the Macquarie Lighthouse, Hyde Park Barracks, the Female Factory in Parramatta, the District Courts, St James Church, Queen's Square, St Matthews Church.

For buildings of grandeur, tiles were made in local factories or imported from abroad. These buildings were usually churches, expensive homes or government offices. For cheap shops and residences, the trusty corrugated iron sheets became the roof of choice. But because iron sheeting carried little prestige, early architects designed in a boom style in which the building's concrete front was built sufficiently high to conceal the unglamorous iron roof.

In the 1880s James Barnet designed sandstone plaques around the colonnade of the General Post Office. However, instead of commemorating the distinguished faces of civic notables, as was common in Europe, Barnet's carvings commemorated the daily work of shearers, postmen and other ordinary Australians.

Around the 1930s, modernism became fashionable and developers started calling for all old buildings to be pulled down and replaced by new ones. The modernist movement gained a boost after World War II as developers argued that Sydney's heritage was not relevant to new migrants and that old buildings needed to be torn down to recognise Sydney as a multicultural society. Such a climate was very conducive to experimentation and an architect named Harry Seidler built his reputation with box designs that seemed completely alien to the Sydney landscape.

The modernist sentiment also created demand for an Opera House to import some high-class European culture into the "barren" landscape of Australia. A world-wide design competition was subsequently won by Dutch architect Jan Utzon. Although highly innovative and completely different to all other Sydney buildings, Utzon's designed resonated with the local population. To some people, the Opera House reminded them of shells that they might find when walking along Sydney's beaches. To others, the Opera House reminded them of the boats that sail in Sydney harbour; however everyone was in agreement that the design was in harmony with the Sydney landscape.

QVB

After the success of the Opera House, councils were consumed with a missionary zeal to continue pulling down old buildings to further the cultural enrichment of Australia. But to informed eyes, the old Australian architecture carried the spiritual and material aspirations of bygone generations. To the open minded, such expressions had value. The conflict between the old and the new came to a head in 1973 over planned redevelopment of the Rocks, an ex-convict settlement overlooking the Opera house. In September 1973, Jack Mundy, then secretary of the Builders' Labourers Federation, raised the Eureka Stockade Flag and led unionists in Australia's first green ban. Although many were arrested, the battle was won and the Rocks were saved. Subsequently BLF greenbans forced a sea change in philosophy and instead of destroying heritage, Sydney architects began working with it. Factories and terrace houses were renovated into high-class accommodation, art studios and theatres. Aside from preserving history, such renovations also proved to be lucrative as high-income earners came to appreciate the sense of belonging that living in a historic house inspires. They also came to appreciate the creativity of an architect who was shackled by need to work with history, yet still found ways to express modern sentiments and lifestyle needs.

Melbourne Architecture

Melbourne

Melbourne's architecture is not for eveyone. Melbourne is a city in which a warehouse conversion might sit alongside an over-stated house of a Greek migrant. Side by side, the two styles simply do not match. For people who are a fan of the synergy and uniformity of design seen in European architecture, the mix represents an eyesore. For others; however, the mix represents a physical manifestation of Melbourne's diverse history, and continued evolution. The mix adds to a sense of cosmopolitism and creativity that local residents love about their city.   

Melbourne was founded in 1835. After gold was discovered in regional Victoria in 1850s, Melbourne became home to an establishment set that craved respectability and tried to achieve it through architecture. Massive and ornate bluestone constructions displayed all the refinement of the Victorian and Gothic styles.

Despite its best efforts, Melbourne was never able to build any world renowned (or even Australia renowned) flagship buildings like Sydney's Opera House or Canberra's Parliament House. Where Melbourne succeeded was in the redesign of its existing architecture. As the inner-city was transformed from slums and industrial sites, architects redesigned the remnants into housing. Churches, breweries, and warehouses were all transformed.

The feeling that previous generations have left traces of the past is arguably Melbourne's greatest asset over instant cities like Canberra. The traces provide a sense of continuity and attachment. Furthermore, they provide a feeling of evolving heritage. Not only is the evolving heritage intriguing in itself, it also fosters an appreciation for the creativity that was able to link multiple generations in architecture. Ironically, the diversity of heritage has a way of giving Melbourne a greater sense of history than some European cities that had their external architecture designed centuries ago, and haven't seen much change ever since.

 

Three Houses - Three Styles

Mix of styles

Melbournian architects have never paid much attention to the buildings around them. Consequently, three neighbouring houses use three different building materials, and three different styles.

 

Federation Square

Federation Square

An attempt by Melbourne to create a flagship building, but the end result is what can best be described as confusion architecture. Federation Square is a building designed for the sake of being different.

Federation Square

City view from Federation Square

The lack of consideration to other designs seen at a residential level, is also seen at a commericial level. The views seen from Federation Square shows that Melbourne architects are very keen on doing their own thing.

City view from Federation Square

Five different buildings and four different styles.

Federation Square

Melbourne Victorian Arts Centre Spire from Federation Square

The Melbourne Victorian Arts Centre Spire was the city's previous attempt to create an architectural building that could be used as a flagship to symbolise the city.

Victoria Brewery

Brewery conversion

The old Victoria Brewery has been converted into apartments. Included in the apartments is a beer museum.

Silo conversion

Silo conversion

Silos converted to apartments.

Church conversion

Church Apartments

A church converted into apartments.

 


Hobart

Built in the coldest Australian state, Hobart's buildings needed to be constructed solidly. Making use of local basalt, granite, sandstone and corrugated iron sheeting, many of these early buildings still stand today.

A fine example of Hobart's colonial architecture are the sandstone warehouses on the harbourfront at Salamanca Place. Built for the whaling industry of the 1830s, they have been redeveloped to house galleries, restaurants, nightspots and shops.

Broad Arrows Cafe PORT Arthur

Broad Arrows cafe at Port Arthur

Another fine example of function conversion can be found at the old convict prison of Port Arthur. Built on an immensely beautiful natural setting, the solid brick buildings conveyed a sense of strength and order. Within the building's walls, convicts suffered some of the worst human rights violations the world has ever seen. When the prison was closed down, the buildings were left in ruins. If they had been in Sydney, they probably would have been demolished and replaced with post-modern apartments. But something about ruins appealed to the locals and in the 70s, walkways were constructed that turned the buildings into a tourist attraction. Thus a building that was designed to punish humans, was being used to entertain them.

In 1996, a lone man gunned down tourists as they sat in a coffee shop overlooking the ruins. The gunman displayed a lack of appreciation for human life not seen since the days when the prison was operational. The coffee shop was subsequently stripped bare, the roof removed and the shell left as a memorial for the dead. A building designed for relaxing, had been redesigned to allow people to feel empathy for those lost. In combination with the old convict ruins, the coffee shop's shell creates an eerie feeling. In combination, they provoke a somber reflection upon human pain.


Adelaide

" Adelaide was once regarded as a city of wowsers (read: puritan spoilsports) and was renowned chiefly for its disproportionately large number of churches. "- lonely planet guide to Adelaide

Adelaide was the only colonial capital not built with Convict labour. This allowed a puritan culture to emerge, and a culture that directed its architectural passion to the construction of Churches.

Brisbane

Brisbane escaped many of the grandeur contests that motivated Melbourne and Sydney architects to design buildings of prestige. Instead, its architects designed buildings that made life enjoyable for their occupants. Many of Brisbane's houses were built on stilts to ensure adequate ventilation in the humid environment. They also had large verandas so tired farmers could sit outside, have a beer and watch the sun go down. Nor was their any shame in having a corrugated iron roof that needed to be concealed with boom architecture. Brisbane's corrugated iron roofs are on display. When it rains, the sound of rain on iron proudly reminds occupants that they live in Australia.

Even as Brisbane's wealth has increased, lifestyle choices have still taken precedence over prestige. Canal developments allowed Queenlanders to live in a big house with a boat for weekend recreation. It seems that Brisbane residents see status in having a good lifestyle rather than a flashy house.

.


Darwin

Darwin's buildings tend be be very new. This is largely because in 1974 a cyclone on Christmas day demolished everything. The most notable building is the Northern Territory Parliament House.  

City

Materials

Style

Sydney

Weatherboard, sandstone

Terrace, warehouse conversion, boom

Melbourne

Bluestone

Boom, neo-gothic, modern, post-modern, minor examples of brutalism

Canberra

Red brick, concrete

Le Corbusier, burst, brutalist, functional, bush

Bush

Corregated iron, mud brick, granite

Bush, federation, georgian

Hobart

Basalt

Colonial, regency

Brisbane

Corregated iron, weatherboard, timber

Renaissance, colonial
 

 

 

[Top]

Customs and Values

The Great Divide
Culture Wars

Aborigines
Status of Aborigines
Australian English
(Strine) Poetic deception
AustraliaVAmerica

Rejects vs weirdos
Australia V Asia
Group v individual
Christianity
Jesus and Convicts
Drinking
Shouts and rounds
Facts
Odd facts of Australia
Etiquette
Important social rules
Immortals

Iconic battlers
Politics
Maintaining minority rule
Tall-poppy syndrome
The misunderstood icon
Traditions
A time to be sombre and to not
Underdog
Siding with the loser

 

-Leaf
Art of Chad.com

Inaccurate stereotypes about Australia