Spare Change for an Old Has-been?
The type of insults that become associated with a club reveal something about a club’s character, but also something about the character of the clubs that make them. A good example Collingwood fans often say there are few fans at Melbourne games because they drive their 4wds to snow during the football season. Considering that skiing and 4WDing are very enjoyable pastimes, it is an insult that has never been likely to fill Melbourne fans with much shame. On their way to the snow, Melbourne fans may even wave to Collingwood fans waiting at the Centrelink bus stop. Furthermore, when they return from the snow, Melbourne fans are not concerned about Collingwood fans insulting them for owning a 4WD but they are concerned about Collingwood fans making plans to steal their 4WD.
Truth be told, the insults of Melbourne are quite bland and generic, which in itself is a reflection of a club that has as much personality as a loaf of bread. Initially known as the 'Invincible Whites', the Melbourne Football Club was formed in 1858 to represent the Melbourne Cricket Club. Without a regional homeland to represent, the club had to rely solely on its culture to attract new fans. As the league was targeted at cricketers wanting to keep fit in the winter, Melbourne's cricketing associations ensured that it had a establishment image that was attractive to the new inductees to the code. As the league expanded and the MCG became the home of football, Melbourne also became the club of choice for MCG and MCC members.
The change from white occured in the1870s when a club official returned from England with a load of red and blue woollen socks. He gave the blue socks to Carlton, and the red to his own team, which inspired the name Redlegs. With colour the new craze, Melbourne added blue knickerbockers and guernsey as well as a red cap. (Officials from Melbourne were so into their colours that they also adopted a club song that pledged loyalty to the colours but didn’t even mention the club. Melbourne is the only club that is not mentioned in its song.)
With the outfit reminding many of flowers, the club officially embraced the title of Fuchsias. This name change led to a degree of conflict between fans and officials. Amongst fans, the name Redlegs remained in poplar use while the officials remained adament the club would be called Fuchsias.
A compromise name was reached in the 1930s when Frank 'Checker' Hughes, the former coach of Richmond, took over as Melbourne coach. A man from the bloodlust culture of the Tigers found little to like about the Fuscias name and told his players,
Hughes’ comment inspired a name change and the club went on to record four premierships during Hughes’reign.
Despite the lack of egalitarian values and an odd obsession with flowers, the club was very popular. Since gold was discovered in the 1850s, Melbourne had been home to Australia's establishment set and was the headquarters of the big Australian companies. The city overflowed with the wealthy and the Demons were their team. With money, connections and a home ground that was also the home of football, the Demons were one of the powerhouses of the VFL. By the 1960s, the club had won 11 premierships and held the VFL attendance records.
In 1964, the club reached he pinnacle of its powers before commencing a decent that it has yet to recover from. Legendary coach Norm Smith won his sixth premiership. The following year he was sacked mid season and replaced with a 72-year-old man who used a walking stick. The Melbourne board never gave an explanation for why he was sacked. As a concession that no valid reason ever existed, the board re-appointed him a couple of weeks later. It was a period of turmoil that the club never recovered from and set the Demons on the path to claim the longest premiership drought in VFL/AFL history.
By 1996, the club's fortunes had reached such a low ebb that the board was forced to take it to the merger table with the Hawthorn Hawks. The merger was skittled after the Hawthorn members refused to approve. As for Demon members, a majority of them voted in favour of their board's actions. This willingness to merge may have been indicative of their lack of passion. Alternatively, it may have been indicative of their inability to feel attached to a culture that to a large extent did not exist. Admitedly, there were a few supporters that protested the merger; however, they wanted to draw a line in the snow rather than a line in the sand. Such actions, as well as teleconference calls from Mount Buller, are just not as persuasive as a rally at the ground.
One supporter who did manage to bypass the snow for the season was mining magnate Joe Gutnik. In the wake of Hawthorn's rejection of the Demons, the billionaire took control of the board and donated $3 million of his own money to help ease the club's financial problems. He reinvigorated it with the face of the wealthy establishment that defined its past glories. Gutnik was arrogant, outspoken and precisely what the club needed.
By 2000, Gutnik had steered the club to a grand final. It was then that infighting started tearing the club apart. An accountant named Szondy argued that he could do a better job and Gutnik was given the boot. But it seemed that balancing books and increasing the popularity of a football club were different skills entirely and Szondy's promises came to nothing. The club fell to the bottom of the ladder, the infighting continued and the small crowds got even smaller.
Faced with financial ruin, the club decided its future lay in China. It then cooked up some kind of scheme that involved sending players on a walk along the Great Wall and pitching the club to Chinese sponsors. Unfortunately, Chinese consider Demons to be unlucky. The club responded by giving itself an exorcism. To appease China, it dropped the Demon from its name to become Melbourne FC. While there was obviously some kind of strategy involved in the Chinese angle, Chinese tend to live in China and for all their population, getting to games at the MCG on the weekend was always going to be a struggle. Consequently, the strategy did very little to address the club's problems with empty stadiums.
Struggling to tap into the Chinese market, the Demons decided that maybe the best way to get crowds was to win a few games of football. Ironically, they felt this would be best achieved by deliberately losing matches in order to improve draft picks. In 2009, this was achieved via a "youth policy" that saw ruckmen being played at full back, forwards played in the ruck, defenders in the forward line and star players left out in favout of rookies. Senior coach Dean Bailey and general manager of football Chris Connolly were later suspended while the club was fined $500,000. Star player Brock McClean requested a trade out of disgust for his club's actions.
Even though the AFL had conceded that Melbourne had tanked for draft picks, the AFL didn’t want to strip Melbourne of those draft picks for fear they would be down the bottom even longer. It was no use as the bad habits and poor culture fostered by trying to get ahead by being losers ensured that Melbourne made little progress on the field. Seven years later, new Melbourne coach Paul Roos, said,
Melbourne struggles because it has very little image. It has no geographic association, no character and no soul. Out of all clubs, the Demons have the lowest number of supporters and even rugby league games in Sydney draw higher crowds. The best analogy for the club is billionaire turned bum asking for hand outs on the street.
Roy Morgan research
Melbourne Demons supporters are:
2001 when compared to other Australians
2004 when compared to other AFL supporters
2006 when compared to other AFL supporters
Melbourne demons theme song
Lots of words that don't really say anything!
Every summer yobbos at the MCG break into the chant "members are wankers!" As the football club of MCC members, in theory the Demons should have a strong rivalry with most of the working class football clubs in Melbourne. In the VFA era, the theory held true as the Demons were seen as the elitist team battling the working class Carlton and clashes between the two were the undisputed highlights of the season.
In the modern era, the Demons have found that few clubs really hate them. The Demon's problem is that they don't have the arrogance of an elitist club. They haven't opened their chequebook to steal players and their fans in typical toffy style, don't show enough emotion to piss people off.
The club has been trying to manufacture a rivalry with the Sydney Swans with an annual clash on ANZAC day. However, because the Swans are a relocated Melbourne club, they are unable to evoke that civic appeal to give the rivalry some real grunt. Furthermore, both teams are lightweights so the clash doesn't represents the titanic battle between Australia's two largest cities as it should.
Melbourne Demon jokes
Due to a lack of culture it is too difficult to make jokes about Melbourne. There is really nothing unique to take the piss out of. Quite boring really.
1900, 1926, 1939-40-41, 1948, 1955-56-57, 1959-60, 1964 (12 total)
Ivor Warne-Smith 1926 & 1928; Don Cordner 1946; Brian Wilson 1982; Peter Moore 1984; Jim Stynes 1991; Shane Woewodin 2000
|Offended by the description of your footy club? Maybe you would be better off watching a TV news report of your team's players in a recovery session standing around in the ocean looking cold. Alternatively, you could listen to news on the radio of your team 'training without incident'. If you are still concerned, then maybe have a read of stereotype formation and suggest a reason for a different steretype.|